Atlantic County Executive Calls for Changes to Atlantic City Casino Tax Scheme
Atlantic County Executive Dennis Levinson Advocates for Reversal of Scheme
Understanding the complexities of your winnings begins with a clear guide, so we have provided this Table of Contents to help you navigate the essential rules of gaming and the impact of casino tax on your total payouts.
Atlantic County Executive Dennis Levinson (R) is strongly opposing the current property tax arrangement for the nine casinos operating in Atlantic City, arguing that it places an unfair financial burden on county taxpayers. He is advocating for a return to the pre-2021 tax structure.

Image: Atlantic County Executive Dennis Levinson
The Payment-in-Lieu-of-Taxes (PILOT) Scheme
The state of New Jersey has implemented a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes (PILOT) scheme for the Atlantic City casinos. This arrangement determines the amount of property taxes the casinos pay to the state, county, and city, based on their gross gaming revenue (GGR). The current PILOT agreement is set to expire at the end of 2026, prompting ongoing discussions and potential amendments within the New Jersey legislature.
Origin of the PILOT Scheme
The PILOT program was established in 2016 as a response to the closure of several casinos between 2014 and 2016. These closures led to legal challenges from the remaining casinos regarding their property tax assessments, which in turn created funding shortages for essential county and city services.
Concerns Raised by Atlantic County Executive Levinson
Executive Levinson contends that a 2021 amendment to the PILOT calculation, specifically the exclusion of revenue from iGaming (online casino gambling) and online sports wagering, has significantly disadvantaged Atlantic County taxpayers. According to Levinson, this change has cost his constituents over $14 million between 2022 and 2024.
The Impact of Excluding iGaming Revenue
The casinos successfully argued that a substantial portion of iGaming revenue flows to third-party operators like DraftKings, which have minimal physical presence in Atlantic City. Levinson’s office has stated that the original PILOT agreement allocated 13.5% of annual PILOT funds to Atlantic County. The removal of iGaming and online sports betting revenue from the tax calculation has resulted in approximately $5 million less in property tax revenue for Atlantic County each year.
Here are some key facts about the PILOT scheme:
- The current PILOT agreement is set to expire at the end of 2026.
- The scheme determines casino property tax payments based on their gross gaming revenue (GGR).
- A 2021 amendment excluded iGaming and online sports betting revenue from the GGR calculation.
- Atlantic County believes this amendment has resulted in over $14 million in lost tax revenue.
Legal Battle and Financial Implications
Atlantic County initiated a lawsuit against the state, alleging that the 2021 amendment violated a 2018 consent order. This order had allocated a larger share of the annual PILOT funds to Atlantic County. The legal battle has incurred over $1.3 million in legal fees for the county.
In 2022, a New Jersey Superior Court judge ruled in favor of Atlantic County, but ongoing appeals have kept the case and the associated funds in a state of uncertainty.
The financial impact on the county is substantial:
- Over $14 million in lost tax revenue (2022-2024).
- More than $1.3 million in legal fees.
Levinson’s Plea to State Lawmakers
In a letter to State Senator Vince Polistina, who is leading discussions on extending the PILOT agreement, Executive Levinson urged lawmakers to prioritize the interests of Atlantic County taxpayers. He argues that the current PILOT structure unfairly burdens the county while providing benefits to the casino industry and other counties in New Jersey.
“The only ‘certainty’ the Atlantic County taxpayers have had since the PILOT is knowing they will continue to pay more than their fair share in taxes while the casinos and Atlantic City will pay less,” Levinson stated.
He expressed disappointment at not being able to meet with Senator Polistina directly and emphasized that casino benefits extend to all 21 counties in New Jersey, not just Atlantic County. He advocates for a new PILOT agreement that considers the interests of all taxpayers.
The Future of the PILOT Scheme
As the current PILOT agreement approaches its expiration, the discussions surrounding its extension are gaining momentum. Executive Levinson’s advocacy for a return to the pre-2021 tax structure highlights the ongoing debate about the fairness and financial implications of the casino tax arrangement in Atlantic City. The outcome of these discussions will have a significant impact on the financial well-being of Atlantic County taxpayers.
Related Topics: Atlantic City Casino Tax,


